If I may ask is there a difference between consulting Nechung and Dorje Shugden? As I understand, it was Nechung who approached Duldzin Drakpa Gyaltsen and requested him to uphold the doctrine of Lama Tsongkhapa as a dharma protector. The great Duldzin complied, showing his recognition towards Nechung who is not even enlightened until now. Without Nechung in the picture, I don't think there would be Dorje Shugden today.
I think the video actually shows a lama chanelling which is different from a protector taking trance in an oracle. The monk in the video is wearing a pandit hat and not the ritual investiture (compulsory when taking full trance during formal occasions). The pandit's hat is awarded only to scholars who have mastered the five sciences, someone who has accomplished the path of no more learning. Protectors do not take trance in Lamas.
Example:
H.E. Kyabje Yongyal Rinpoche is a powerful practitioner but the protector does not take trance in him. There was an oracle during the opening of Serpom Monastery. http://www.shugdentoday.com/?p=9065
Hi Dhiman,
Yes, of course there is a difference. Nechung is Nechung and Dorje Shugden is Dorje Shugden. Both are different beings. Nechung is an oath bound Dharma protector that existed from the time of Guru Rinpoche who put him under oath to protect the Dharma. He was a spirit that was brought over from Persia, thus he has another name which is Pehar. You can read about Pehar/Nechung's history here:
http://dorjeshugden.com/wp/?p=3938 He is not considered as enlightened, but apparently he will soon be enlightened and Dorje Shugden will take his place as the official Dharma protector of Tibet. Perhaps, the ban is to clear the self created obstacles of the Tibetans who are massive from years of being in denial and also of years and years of destroying the Dharma from receiving Dorje Shugden as their official protector.
The lama is not channeling Dorje but he is in full trance of Dorje Shugden's peaceful form. Dorje Shugden when in trance has 2 forms: the wrathful form which will don the exact same attire as Nechung and Setrap's oracle, and the peaceful form that takes the appearance of a high lama wearing a yellow hat. Dorje Shugden is Tulku Dragpa Gyaltsen, who is a fully ordained monk who can teach the Dharma and who holds the vows perfectly. Therefore in trance, he appears in the form of a monk so that he can talk to more people as the wrathful form can tax the body of the oracle and cannot be done for extended periods of time while the peaceful form is less taxing. In this form, he is known to give Dharma talks and even initiations. For this form, he wears the attire of a high lama, complete with a pandit's hat.
This is the one thing that sets Dorje Shugden apart from other oracles: he has the ability to give teachings and Dharma talks while in trance, especially for his peaceful form as the wrathful form can probably last around 1-2 hours since it does tax the oracle's body. No other protector can do this while in trance and the most they can do is answer questions that are presented to them. Also, when Dorje Shugden takes trance, it is the high lamas that pay respect to him, while when Nechung takes trance, he has to pay respects to the high lamas. This indicates that Dorje Shugden is indeed a high lama taking the form of a yaksha so that he can be closer to us and so that he can act and relate more to our problems and to us in general. This also shows that he is higher in precedence as compared to Nechung.
This is another picture of him in his peaceful form:
Dulzin or Dorje Shugden in peaceful form taking full trance of Choyang Kuten (oracle) and giving prophecy, advice and pujas to be done for the betterment of the monastery for the coming year. It is this oracle during trance that discovered the locations of many great tulkus of Sera, Drepung and Gaden upon consultation. The great incarnations of the current Kyabje Pabongkha Rinpoche, Kyabje Zong Rinpoche and Kyabje Trijang Rinpoche were found by this great oracle.
Dulzin by the way, is a title given to monks who hold the vows purely.