Author Topic: Say what? Tibetan Youth Congress Do Not Wanna Follow The Dalai Lama's way?!  (Read 10699 times)

jagger

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 46
  • For the love of Shugden
For me, I still think that the Dalai Lama should not mix with all these political issues so much and leave it to the lay people in CTA to deal with it. I feel that if this is really the case, Dharma might be able to grow and spread even faster, helping all that would need it.

At the same time, I feel that it is time for the CTA to take the problems into their own hands, and not fully relying on the Sanghas to solve the problems. Instead, allow the Sanghas to do the spiritual work that they need to, and ask for advises only during times of need.

As much as our opinions hold water that politics should not be mixed with religion, we all come from a background so much different than the Tibetan society where spirituality is the heart essence of every Tibetan. Since its advent of civilization, everything was religious to begin with. There was no way that Tibet could live without having religion especially that of Buddhism take centrestage of whatever its pursuit is.

As civilization expands and also progress, there is a need for a system to govern the land in a proper manner and politics came into being. So if we would like to separate these two for Tibet, we would first need to understand and go through what the forefathers of this peace loving people went through before making such a statement.

And as time passes, things become more different and society evolves and requires a different aspect of managing a country. Keeping his vows and prayers for the welfare of all, the Dalai Lama took many courageous means to help keep its people until today. Even the ban on Dorje Shugden is seen as means to help the Buddha Dharma grow and flourish over time especially when HHDL passes on.

If the TYC comes up with retaliation, I am sure HHDL does hear their voices, but the TYC needs to do an internal reflection if they are able to shoulder on a job so difficult to achieve
Jaggerboy

Ensapa

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 4124
    • Email
As much as our opinions hold water that politics should not be mixed with religion, we all come from a background so much different than the Tibetan society where spirituality is the heart essence of every Tibetan. Since its advent of civilization, everything was religious to begin with. There was no way that Tibet could live without having religion especially that of Buddhism take centrestage of whatever its pursuit is.

As civilization expands and also progress, there is a need for a system to govern the land in a proper manner and politics came into being. So if we would like to separate these two for Tibet, we would first need to understand and go through what the forefathers of this peace loving people went through before making such a statement.

And as time passes, things become more different and society evolves and requires a different aspect of managing a country. Keeping his vows and prayers for the welfare of all, the Dalai Lama took many courageous means to help keep its people until today. Even the ban on Dorje Shugden is seen as means to help the Buddha Dharma grow and flourish over time especially when HHDL passes on.

If the TYC comes up with retaliation, I am sure HHDL does hear their voices, but the TYC needs to do an internal reflection if they are able to shoulder on a job so difficult to achieve

But unfortunately, the actions of the Tibetans do not reflect that they are spiritual! What they are doing is not even humanitarian but worse than that. There would be no problems if the Tibetans were truly spiritual to begin with, but unfortunately their actions do not reflect that at all. And im not talking about sending your kids to the monastery or sending regular donations to the monasteries. It's about general attitude...and from the way they act about rangzen and also on the Dorje Shugden ban, it is pretty obvious that they did not put anything into practice, thus they're not spiritual.

Rinchen

  • Global Moderator
  • Sr. Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 407
Yes, it is true that they way of how Tibet is being governed may balled off from a spiritual point of view, but it is now so political. Then why would even anyone that is spiritual want to be involved when things are getting so political? They want to play a part in it because of the "fame" and "recognition" that would come along with their "responsibilities".

True that the CTA can blame everything on Nechung, but people are not blind, they will soon know what is really going on and go against it. Like how TYC is now going against Dalai Lama.

With time, there must be results, but there are no results at all. This shows that whatever method that they are using is not suitable at all, but they are not willing to change it. Why? Because the CTA is not taking on the responsibilities that they should be taking on, and also not carrying out the actions that they should be doing.

Ensapa

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 4124
    • Email
Yes, it is true that they way of how Tibet is being governed may balled off from a spiritual point of view, but it is now so political. Then why would even anyone that is spiritual want to be involved when things are getting so political? They want to play a part in it because of the "fame" and "recognition" that would come along with their "responsibilities".

True that the CTA can blame everything on Nechung, but people are not blind, they will soon know what is really going on and go against it. Like how TYC is now going against Dalai Lama.

With time, there must be results, but there are no results at all. This shows that whatever method that they are using is not suitable at all, but they are not willing to change it. Why? Because the CTA is not taking on the responsibilities that they should be taking on, and also not carrying out the actions that they should be doing.

They're just too insecure about their own heritage to be honest. Which is why they came to Dharamsala in an effort to preserve their Tibetan heritage. But unfortunately, they dont know how to adapt or innovate and the results are what we can see now. There is evidence that the Tibetan Government was bad even back in the 17th Century as they were not efficient in preventing crime or even taking care of the Tibetans in the first place. So they're just continuing the tradition without wanting to improve anything at all.. how sad.