Obama: ‘We are not in favor of independence’

You have to consider the tactics of the CTA and His Holiness the Dalai Lama in pursuit of the ’freedom’ of Tibet has not borne fruit. They have been courting Western Governments for the last 50 years which is not working as they all believe Tibet is part of China. The West has no influence over the sovereign and powerful nation of China in relations to Tibet. No Western Government can force China to do anything if they do not wish to. The West needs China but not Tibet. The axis of power is shifting towards the East and specifically to China. The courting of Western powers has gotten CTA sponsorship for their activities in Dharamsala and that is about it. Has this achieved the purpose of the Tibetan nation in obtaining their so called independence or autonomy? Of course not. CTA is not any closer at all to this end, if anything farther from their goal. The Tibetan leadership should have changed their tactics long ago and should have become friends with China. To stop all activities that irritate China and harm further what’s left of the bilateral relations. China does not need CTA but on the contrary. China is as big as the planet Jupiter compared to the Tibetan leadership in Dharamsala which is likened to a floating tiny asteroid without any destination. The asteroid can do no damage to Jupiter whatsoever.

The Dorje Shugden people are accused of taking money from China and befriending China. Which is really not true. But if that is the case, CTA should do what the purported Shugden people are doing. Making friends with China and cooperating with them will help Chinese leaders become less hardline and change their policies in Tibet towards preserving religion, culture and language. China can do anything they want in Tibet and if the world is not happy, what happens? A torrent of hate China messages appear on social media and then it blows over as usual. No Western government will interfere and take action against China. Their economies are intimately intertwined. No Western nation will jeopardize their hundreds of billions if not trillions in trade deals with China for Tibet. Tibet has nothing to offer the world in the economic sense. Tibet has offered the Dalai Lama but he does not generate or sustain the national economy. The Dalai Lama is now 79 years old and how long more can he live? Once the Dalai Lama is no more, you will not see another able Tibetan leader step into his shoes and have any effect on any government. If someone could replace the Dalai Lama they would be wise to be friends with China. The straightforward and carve-in-stone fact is that Tibet is part of China and it would be wise for Tibetans to make friends with China to better the life of their countrymen.

Since the Shugden lamas in Tibet are friends with China as Tibet is a part of China and they really don’t have a choice, it would be wise to not suppress the practice of Dorje Shugden and hurt the sentiments of these powerful lamas with their powerful connections. All funds, buildings, roads, schools, hospitals, approvals, public services in Tibet comes from the Chinese government funding. What further need is there to explain the simple equation that CTA must make friends with China. If the Tibetans inside Tibet and outside of Tibet work with the Chinese government, relations will grow and it will become easier for all Tibetans in every sense. Tibetan Leadership and Dalai Lama should make friends with the Dorje Shugden lamas in Tibet and around the world to open better communications with Beijing. In fact, the friendlier CTA are, the better it will benefit the preservation of Tibetan language, religion and culture within Tibet. Since China supports the growth of Dorje Shugden monasteries and Lamas, CTA will be wiser if they don’t contradict this policy. To ban Shugden practice, Shugden practitioners, Shugden lamas and ostracize them is the wrong move by the CTA. The more they ban Shugden, the bigger China will help Shugden to grow bigger to oppose CTA. Once the 79 year old Dalai Lama is no more, Tibet and Tibetans will have to embrace or at least peacefully tolerate Shugden practice. Better they remove the ban against Shugden and start humbling themselves and start contacting China. Stop locking horns with China as CTA’s horns are no match for China. You see, it’s very simple. China can do whatever they like in Tibet and CTA has no say at all. If CTA wants to play hardball, they will be the loser in the end as they have no power over Tibet. Some Tibetans accuse Shugden Tibetans for selling out their country by being friendly with China. This is just plain illogical hysteria meted out by CTA to cover their failures. Tibet is a part of China and that is a fact. By Tibetans being friendly with China, they are making friends with the nation they belong to and making it easier for other Tibetans living within Tibet.  For the last 50 years, has there been any progress in solving the Tibet question from the side of the CTA? The answer is sadly no. CTA needs to remove the ban as this offends China and humble down and request for fresh talks agreeing to China’s demands while the Dalai Lama is alive. If not, it will be inevitable after the Dalai Lama has passed on, all Tibetans will have to cooperate with China.

Kay Beswick

***

‘We are not in favor of independence’: President Barack Obama reiterates U.S. position that Tibet is part of China

• Obama said he encouraged Chinese authorities ‘to take steps to preserve the unique cultural, religious and linguistic identity of the Tibetan people’

• He shared the same viewpoint with exiled Tibetan leader His Holiness the XIV Dalai Lama when he visited the White House earlier this year

• The Dalai Lama told Obama during their meeting that he doesn’t want independence for Tibet – he wants autonomy

• Obama also said today that he and Chinese President Xi Jinping ‘had a very healthy exchange’ about human rights issues

• ‘China stands ready to have dialogue with the United States on human rights issues,’ Xi told reporters

By Francesca Chambers for MailOnline

Published: 10:14 EST, 12 November 2014 | Updated: 12:42 EST, 12 November 2014

President Barack Obama reaffirmed on Wednesday the United States’ position that Tibet is ‘part of the People’s Republic of China.’

‘We are not in favor of independence,’ Obama said during a joint press conference in Beijing with Chinese President Xi Jinping.

‘But we did encourage Chinese authorities to take steps to preserve the unique cultural, religious and linguistic identity of the Tibetan people,’ the U.S. leader said.

No change: President Barack Obama said today during a press conference with Chinese President Xi Jinping in Beijing that the U.S. still does not support independence for Tibet

Obama, left, is pictured here shaking hands with Chinese President Xi Jinping, right, after a joint press conference at the Great Hall of People. Obama paid a state visit to China after attending the 22nd Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) Economic Leaders’ Meeting

Obama has been unwavering in his stance that Tibet should remain under the control of China, sharing the same viewpoint with exiled Tibetan leader His Holiness the XIV Dalai Lama when he visited the White House earlier this year.

After the February meeting the White House said in a statement similar to the one offered by Obama today that the president expressed ‘strong support’ for traditions and ‘the protection of human rights for Tibetans.’

‘The President stressed that he encourages direct dialogue to resolve long-standing differences and that a dialogue that produces results would be positive for China and Tibetans,’ the White House said, and explained that the U.S. does not back independence for the region.

In response, the White House said the Dalai Lama ‘stated that he is not seeking independence for Tibet and hopes that dialogue between his representatives and the Chinese government will resume.’

Careful not to anger the Chinese, who said at the time that the meeting was ‘a gross interference in China’s internal affairs’ and ‘a serious violation of the norms of international relation,’ the White House kept the president’s hour-long one on one with spiritual leader of Tibet mostly quiet, keeping both his entrance and exit from the president’s home out of sight from photographers.

In today’s overseas press conference Obama advocated on behalf of Tibet without formally taking its side in its dispute with China, citing ‘America’s unwavering support for fundamental human rights of all people.’

Obama said he and President Xi ‘had a very healthy exchange around these issues,’ and he told the Chinese head that ‘it is so important for us to speak out for the freedoms that we believe are universal, rights that we believe are the birthright of all men and women, wherever they live, whether it is in New York or Paris or Hong Kong.’

Continuing, Obama said, ‘We think history shows that nations that uphold these rights – including for ethnic and religious minorities – are ultimately more prosperous, more successful, and more able to achieve the dreams of their people.’

President Obama is pictured here meeting with His Holiness the Dalai Lama in the Map Room of the White House on Feb. 18, 2010. The president traditionally meets with important world leaders in the Oval Office, but when the exiled Tibetan leader comes, he alway speaks with him in the less prestigious setting

The Dalai Lama, left, wasn’t event allowed to exit the White House through the front door when he visited Obama in 2010. He was forced to walk out the doors of the Palm Room, passing by trash bags waiting to be picked up due to delays from a snow storm

In a statement following Obama’s remarks President Xi said he had a ‘candid discussion’ with his U.S. counterpart on the topic of human rights. He then pointed out that ‘over the last three decades and more of China’s reform and opening era, China has made enormous progress in its human rights.

‘That is a fact recognized by all the people in the world,’ he added, according to a White House transcript of the press conference.

That said, ‘we should never consider our work to be mission accomplished,’ Xi told reporters. ‘It’s always work in progress, and there is always room for further improvement.

‘China stands ready to have dialogue with the United States on human rights issues on the basis of equality and mutual respect so that we can constructively handle our differences, deepen our mutual understanding, and learn from each other.’

The U.S. has always walked a tightrope in regards to its relations with both China, a fellow world power that holds a significant amount of U.S. debt, and Tibet, whom it recognizes has been mistreated at the hands of the Chinese.

Since a 1959 uprising in Tibet, the country’s leader has lived in exile in India. China has subsequently painted him as a subversive whom the international community cannot trust.

The Dalai Lama professes non-violence in the battle for autonomy in his native region, but the Chinese say he is a ‘wolf in sheep’s clothing’ and privately supports a violent takeover.

‘The Dalai is definitely not a pure religious figure. He is using the cloak of religion to engage in long-term activities to separate China. He is a political exile,’ Chinese Foreign Ministry spokeswoman Hua Chunying said in a statement preceding the February 2014 meeting.

Meanwhile, human rights groups have accused China of using perverted methods themselves to keep Tibet’s residents in line.

The U.S. State Department even issued a report in 2012 acknowledging the abuses and noted that ‘the government’s respect for and protection of human rights…deteriorated markedly’ in the preceding year.

‘Under the banner of maintaining social stability, the government engaged in the severe repression of Tibet’s unique religious, cultural, and linguistic heritage by, among other means, strictly curtailing the civil rights of China’s ethnic Tibetan population, including the freedoms of speech, religion, association, and movement,’ reads the State Department’s report.

‘Other serious human rights abuses included extrajudicial killings, torture, arbitrary arrests, extrajudicial detentions, and house arrests,’ it said.

According to Reuters, more than 120 Tibetans – mostly monks and nuns – have protested China’s brutal rule of the territory by lighting themselves of fire.

Smile for the cameras: President Xi and Obama participate in a welcoming ceremony at the Great Hall of the People upon Obama’s arrival

The U.S. and China have long been on shaky terms and Obama has tried to bolster the relationship by staying neutral in the country’s dispute with Tibet while acknowledging that parent country has oppressed and abused Tibet’s people

During the Dalai Lama’s visit to Washington, D.C. nine months ago, then-White House Press Secretary Jay Carney told reporters the Obama administration was ‘concerned about continuing tensions and that the deteriorating human rights situation in Tibetan areas of China.’

As such, the Obama spokesman said, ‘We will continue to urge the Chinese government to resume dialogue with the Dalai Lama or his representatives without pre-conditions as a means to reduce tensions.’

The visit marked the third time the president had invited the ‘internationally respected religious and cultural leader’ to the White House since taking office. Previously the Dalai Lama and Obama met in February of 2010 and July of 2011.

After the 2010 meeting, the Dalai Lama was photographed leaving 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue unceremoniously through a side door, where piles of not yet disposed trash were heaped in the snow.

This year photographers never said the Nobel Peace Prize laureate coming or going. However, the White House said the meeting was held in the Map Room – not the prestigious Oval Office where the president usually holds important meetings and entertains world leaders.

No U.S. president has ever sat down with the Dalai Lama in the Oval Office, the White House has said.

The snubs are ostensibly meant to cool tensions with the Chinese over the assignations, though the White House refused in February to go on the record with an explanation.

‘We don’t have photographers in every meeting the president has,’ Carney told inquiring reporters.

THE TIBET TANGO

World leaders have struggled for years to find appropriate ways to maintain positive relations with the Dalai Lama while remaining loyal to China, which often punishes countries whose heads show favoritism to the exiled cultural and spiritual icon.

China suspended high-level diplomatic ties with Britain in 2012 for the next year in response to British Prime Minister Cameron and Deputy PM Nick Clegg’s decision to meet with the Dalai Lama in London.

Afterward, Cameron refused to apologize for the face to face discussion, but he did promise not to visit with His Holiness again any time soon.

China also broke off diplomatic communications with Norway after it awarded a Chinese dissident the Nobel Peace Prize in 2010.

Seeking to avoid a new confrontation with China, Norwegian officials refused to see the Dalai Lama earlier this year when he came to the country to celebrate the 25th anniversary of his own Nobel Prize.

After German Chancellor Angela Merkel entertained the exiled Tibetan leader in 2007, China bowed out of forthcoming meeting in the country on the protection of intellectual property rights ‘for technical reasons.’

Likewise, China called off a summit with the European Union in 2008 after then-French President and EU head Nicolas Sarkozy agreed to meet the Dalai Lama and other Nobel Prize winners while in Poland.

President Barack Obama has met with the Dalai Lama three times since taking office. And while the Chinese government has responded with outrage every time, the U.S. has not been shunned the way European countries have fit its actions.

‘Internationally, if Beijing does not show anger or protest in the strongest terms, the fear is that many heads of states will meet the Dalai Lama,’ Wenran Jiang, a professor of political science professor at the University of Alberta, told CNN after Obama’s first meeting with His Holiness.

‘So Chinese leaders want to show as much disincentives as possible, even though they know they cannot stop such meetings.’

Reported by: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2831586/We-not-favor-independence-President-Barack-Obama-reiterates-U-S-position-Tibet-China.html