Dear friends of the Dharma,
We are most happy to share with you a most interesting story about two great beings: Lama Zopa Rinpoche and the female oracle, known respectfully as Khadro-la.
Oracles are special people who are trained to take trance of higher beings or enlightened Dharma Protectors. They hold an especially esteemed role within the Tibetan Buddhist lineage, providing a direct, physical link between us and these attained beings. Many of the highest Lamas, including the Dalai Lama, enjoy very close relationships with these oracles and often consult these attained beings through them.
The greatly respected Lama Zopa Rinpoche is particularly close to Khadro-la, the female oracle of the worldly Goddess Tenma and is often seen performing rituals and in Dharma activity together. (see the links below for further information about Lama Zopa and Khadro-la).
During Lama Zopa’s illness, it was known that this oracle Khadro-la was helping Lama Zopa to heal. There are mentions about her help and Lama Zopa’s health on FMPT’s official website, written by Lama Zopa’s main attendant, Ven. Roger:
Click on image to enlarge
Source: http://www.fpmt.org/teachers/zopa/rinpoches-health-updates-and-practices.html
There are also videos of Khadro-la helping Lama Zopa in his recovery:
Or watch on server | download video (right click & save file)
While this is wonderful and of course very kind of Khadro-la, this raised several questions within the Buddhist community, which have been discussed on online forums. This is why:
It was well known that Lama Zopa, and his Guru Lama Yeshe (the founder of FPMT) were greatly devoted to the enlightened Dharma Protector Dorje Shugden and propitiated his practice strongly among their students. Then, in the late 1990s, H.H. the 14th Dalai Lama declared that no one should practice this Protector Dorje Shugden any longer, suddenly claiming that he was a spirit (although he has been clearly recognized as an enlightened protector for hundreds of years). This sacred 350-year-old practice followed by thousands of the holiest lamas and practitioners was suddenly banned.
FPMT were one of the organizations who, under Lama Zopa’s guidance, followed the ban and gave up the practice. A highly attained incarnated Lama like Zopa Rinpoche will have his many good reasons for this but he has always remained respectful towards this issue and not created further problems for people who chose to continue the practice of Dorje Shugden. However, it has become known that students of his organization, FPMT, have acted in quite unkindly ways towards other Dorje Shugden devotees – ostracizing them, talking badly about them or the practice, spreading rumors to undermine these practitioners’ support and sponsorship.
We believe that whatever reasons Lama Zopa may have for not continuing the practice of Shugden, he would not advise his students to act in such schismatic and unkind ways. By acting like this, his students break samaya (spiritual bond and loyalty) not only to their teacher Lama Zopa, but also to Lama Yeshe, the lineage Gurus and the Protector Dorje Shugden himself.
Now, during Lama Zopa’s illness, we hear that it is an oracle of an unenlightened goddess who is being called to help him heal. Surely, an enlightened being like Lama Zopa does not need an unenlightened being to do healing for him? That is saying that unenlightened beings are more powerful than attained ones, which is not logical. Lama Zopa is a recognised Tulku (reincarnated high Lama), with full control of his deaths and rebirths. If he is able to control this, why would he not be able to control his own illness and healing? Why would he need such an oracle to help him heal?
By requesting dakini oracles to heal Lama Zopa, his students and organization FPMT are directly putting down Lama Zopa and his enlightened attainments. Why would such an accomplished Lama ask a worldly deity to heal him or seek advice from a worldly deity? Why would he entertain and spend so much time with this worldly deity’s female oracle? Why is Lama Zopa doing this when their organization used to rely on such a powerful enlightened protector before? Why not just rely on an enlightened Buddha, such as Shakyamuni or Tsongkhapa whose attainments are without question?
It seems that by entertaining this worldly deity oracle, Lama Zopa is sending a message that times have become so degenerate among his organization and students, that he now has to “rely” on a worldly being to cure him. Because of broken samaya among the students and in the FPMT organization, Lama Zopa is not able to manifest his full abilities and powers. He has had to “lower” himself to a level that seems fallible and unable to heal himself. He is being healed now, not even by an enlightened Protector, but by a worldly, unenlightened being.
Attached is an extract from the forum of DorjeShugden.com, where many Buddhists practitioners debate various subjects related to Dharma and especially to this Dharma Protector Dorje Shugden. These particular posts here relate to this topic of Lama Zopa’s illness and his reliance on Khadro-la. Please read the comments and what fellow Buddhists around the world have to say about this – it provides a very interesting perspective to the situation, to Lama Zopa’s health condition and to this delicate aspect of samaya from his students.
We urge you all to think about the serious implications that this has and what large questions it raises about the importance of keeping pure samaya with our teachers, their instructions to us and the lineage practices. Lama Zopa is no ordinary being. The manifestation of his illness and this subsequent move to rely on an unenlightened deity is evidence that something is very wrong among his students. It is very important they repair their samaya quickly – that would be the best balm to cure their beloved teacher.
With great concern,
DorjeShugden.com | DorjeShugden.net | XiongDeng.com
Some Selected Posts on the Forum Topic “Dakini Healing Lama Zopa”
This topic was started by “thaimonk” (http://www.dorjeshugden.com/forum/index.php?topic=1164.0)
FPMT has contacted this Tibetan woman and oracle to help Lama Zopa heal. Suddenly FPMT have such tremendous faith in her. FPMT says that she is not taking trance of a dakini but SHE IS A LIVING DAKINI.
She originally came from Tibet and during a public teaching with Dalai Lama in Dharamsala starting to take trance. Dalai Lama accepted she takes trance of a Goddess (Tema).
Years ago, Lama Yeshe and Lama Zopa relied fully on Shugden and Shugden oracle to help them. Lama Yeshe relied on the Shugden oracle till the end of his days. Does it seem inappropriate they are relying on a Dakini now instead of Shugden? Either way, FPMT is really on a oracle. Shouldn’t Lama Zopa being a high lama be more ‘powerful’ than the dakini from Dharamsala?
I am not sure of this. I don’t have any negative thoughts or such. I was just wondering. What do you all think?
Responses and further comments
Posted by: “DharmaDefender”
I think Lama Zopa’s students would do well to remember their own guru’s teachings on how to extend the life of their lama. Like what dsiluvu said, how comes they can ask a spirit for help but cannot rely on Dorje Shugden? How can they entrust their lama’s long life to a spirit, but apparently practicing Dorje Shugden will shorten his life?
No offence and I’m sure they all mean well (and I sincerely mean that), but relying on an unenlightened being, after breaking their protector practice, kind of smacks of desperation and hypocrisy.
Posted by: “thor”
I think FPMT would be better off directing their efforts towards requesting Lama Zopa to extend his life and heal himself. Long life prayers, rituals and individual transformation and purification of wrong actions would be more effective than medical treatment or mystical help from the oracle.
If the lama can manifest sickness, then of course the lama will be able to make the sickness heal. And there is no reason for the lama to become ill, or to shorten his life, unless it is a method towards something much greater.
My own lama has often told me that no matter how many prayers the students do, how many requests they make, how much medicine and treatment they offer to their lama, none of that will have effect if the lama does not wish to heal. So FPMT should direct their attention towards analysing what it is they should do to please the mind of their lama that he will extend his life.
Posted by: “honeydakini”
I don’t think there is any harm in consulting enlightened beings, oracles, dharma protectors for help or advice, though we should really only consult them if they’re enlightened. I don’t really understand the point in consulting someone who is unenlightened since you open the doors for so many other potentially harmful beings to come in and disturb you.
As to this case of Lama Zopa’s illness, i don’t think anything would work better than for the students to check in on themselves – what commitments they have broken, or what actions they have done that would be against what their teachers have advised or taught them. Perhaps it is not something that they have directly disobeyed, it could even be something that isn’t as obvious like creating schism among Dharma practitioners, or creating doubt in other people’s minds about their practices and their teachers.
I personally think it’s quite silly to consult a dakini when your own enlightened teacher is right there. If you consult a dakini (whether she’s enlightened or not), that is to say that your teacher doesn’t have any control over his own body! I’m sure an enlightened teacher like Lama Zopa would have full control over his health and illnesses. (he has full control over his rebirths, as a tulku, but no control over illness? it doesn’t make sense).
So If our lama has control, that means that he has already taught us the means to heal him – which i’m sure would be, like all teachers advise us, to follow his instructions to us and practice and improve our minds. That would be so much more powerful than a dakini’s advice – because whatever the dakini could “prescribe” , I’m sure it isn’t something that Lama Zopa is beyond doing for himself.
Posted by: “Big Uncle”
Well, the very fact that FPMT is relying on a Dakini to heal their Lama shows that they are insecure about their samaya and the pujas that they can do to heal their own Lama. How much can this Dakini (enlightened or not) heal the Lama when the elders of the organisation know it is through clean samaya and sincere propitiation is the only way to purify lots of negative karma and move Lama Zopa to remain.
On top of that, they seemed to imply that the oracle lady is an enlightened dakini when she is not. Last time I checked, the goddess Tenma is a powerful but unenlightened mountain goddess of Tibet. Why rely on an unenlightened deity like Tenma? This all seemed very strange to me. I don’t think the politically correct elders would dare propitiated Dorje Shugden but in actuality, he is the only one who can help save the situation now. It is so sad.
Posted by: “Benny”
Yes, I could not agree more with Big Uncle, FPMT please mend your broken Samaya! As the saying goes “barking up the wrong tree !” Lama Zopa has full control over whether he stays or leave, there is nothing that the “mountain goddess” can do to move the lama to stay as he is here solely for the students.
What a sad sight to see such an attained Lama playing along with his students. In such crucial times, shouldn’t one propitiate to ones protector rather than a ” living dakini ” who channels an unenlightened deity (confusing ) ? They the FPMT are risking loosing their guru for the sake of looking good in the eyes of the Dalai Lama!
Further information about Lama Zopa and Khadro-la, the female oracle of Tenma.
There is a long-standing relationship between Lama Zopa and this female oracle, Khadro-la. Their closeness has even been documented in some of the most popular Buddhist magazines and resources.
Venerable Roger did an interview with Khadro-la in 2009, for Mandala Magazine (FPMT’s official magazine):
Click on image to enlarge
Source: http://www.mandalamagazine.org/archives/mandala-issues-for-2009/january/interview-with-a-dakini/
There are several videos of Lama Zopa and Khadro-la, engaged in pujas together:
Lama Zopa, Phari Rinpoche and Khadro-la doing puja at Trijang Rinpoche’s stupa:
Or watch on server | download video (right click & save file)
Lama Zopa and Kharo-la doing puja, May 2010:
Or watch on server | download video (right click & save file)
Lama Zopa, Khadro-la, Phari Rinpoche at the Maratika Caves, June 2010
Or watch on server | download video (right click & save file)
Official news on the FPMT websites often feature Lama Zopa together with Khadro-la:
Click on image to enlarge
Source: http://mandala.fpmt.org/2013/lama-zopa-rinpoche-and-khadro-la/
Click on image to enlarge
Click on image to enlarge
Source: www.mandalamagazine.org/2012/lama-zopa-rinpoche-and-khadro-la-visit-western-united-states/
Some photos of Lama Zopa and Khadro-la, who travel and attend religious ceremonies together very often.
For further reading:
Where is Lama Yeshe? (http://www.dorjeshugden.com/all-articles/features/where-is-lama-yeshe/)
FPMT Lineage Masters are Dorje Shugden Believers (http://www.dorjeshugden.com/all-articles/features/fpmt-lineage-masters-are-believers-of-dorje-shugden/)
FPMT, Dalai Lama and Dorje Shugden (http://www.dorjeshugden.com/all-articles/features/fpmt-dalai-lama-and-dorje-shugden/)
A True Inspiration: Claudio Cipullo (http://www.dorjeshugden.com/all-articles/news/a-true-inspiration-claudio-cipullo/)
Fabrizio Pallotti (http://www.dorjeshugden.com/all-articles/news/fabrizio-pallotti/)
Politically Correct at the Expense of the Lineage (http://www.dorjeshugden.com/all-articles/the-controversy/politically-correct-at-the-expense-of-the-lineage/)
Lama Yeshe and Geshe Rabten (http://www.dorjeshugden.com/mail-out/lama-yeshe-and-geshe-rabten/)
The Broken Samayas of FPMT (http://www.dorjeshugden.com/all-articles/the-controversy/the-broken-samayas-of-fpmt/)
The Questionable Policies of the FPMT (http://www.dorjeshugden.com/all-articles/the-controversy/the-questionable-policies-of-the-fpmt/)
Lama Zopa admitted to being recognized by Dorje Shugden (http://www.dorjeshugden.com/others-old/lama-zopa-admitted-to-being-recognized-by-dorje-shugden/)
Recognized by Dorje Shugden, but Speaks against Dorje Shugden (http://www.dorjeshugden.com/all-articles/the-controversy/recognized-by-dorje-shugden-but-speaks-against-dorje-shugden/)
Kopan Monks Asking for Dorje Shugden Puja for Lama Zopa (http://www.dorjeshugden.com/all-articles/the-controversy/kopan-monks-asking-for-dorje-shugden-puja-for-lama-zopa/)
Who made Lama Zopa a Rinpoche? (http://www.dorjeshugden.com/all-articles/features/who-made-lama-zopa-a-rinpoche/)
A Tribute to Ven. Lama Yeshe Rinpoche (http://www.dorjeshugden.com/great-masters/a-tribute-to-ven-lama-yeshe-rinpoche/)
English
Indonesia
Tibetan
just a simple dharma practitioner
August 5, 2012
Um….why is it that people make such ignorant comments about Khadro-la when it seems very obvious that no one here has any clue about who she is or her status? For your information, this lady is not only an oracle for a mountain goddess, but she is also considered an emanation of Tara and Vajrayogini. Last I heard, Tara and Vajrayogini ARE enlightened Buddhas, so what would this make Khadro-la? There is a LOT more to this lady that *just* her connection with the oracle. Her oracle role is only ONE facet of her duties and abilities. Khadro-la channels an unenlightened oracle, but that is just ONE of the things she does and you can bet she does a whole LOT more than just that. Her being an oracle is NOT the sum total of ALL that she is. People need to understand that a tulku can be an emanation of MORE THAN ONE being and she is not ONLY an emanation of the mountain goddess. See, this is the crucial point that people are truly overlooking. If she was *ONLY* an emanation of the mountain goddess, then you people would have a good argument, BUT since she is ALSO an emanation of Tara and/or Vajrayogini (especially Tara) then your argument falls on its face. Sorry, but you just simply cannot make a point in comparing her to worldly protectors because she IS enlightened and she is NOT *just* a mountain deity. She is TARA and (from what I have gathered) Tara is enlightened.
just a simple dharma practitioner
August 6, 2012
Just to follow up on my last comment….I am not clear about whether she is considered to be an emanation of the Goddess Tenma, or whether she merely serves as a channel for the goddess. However, that doesn’t change the fact that Khadro-la IS an emanation of Tara and/or Vajrayogini. I have heard this a number of times from various sources, so I’m surprised that none of you have heard this as well.
As for lamas healing themselves in general, it seems that most of the legitimate high lamas do not make any special claims about being healers, either on themselves or others.The Dalai Lama himself says that he is not a healer and he even pointed out that if he were a healer, he would not need medical treatment for his health problems. Lamas do emphasize the importance of unbroken samaya in order to prolong the lama’s life, but that doesn’t mean samaya is the *ONLY* factor in helping lamas live longer. There are probably many factors, causes and conditions, just like there are with anything.
It’s true that if lamas are supposed to be able to heal themselves, this doesn’t make much sense, if one clings to the belief that lamas can magically snap their fingers and heal themselves whenever they want to. But it seems that the high lamas are not requiring us to believe that they can heal themselves, nor do they seem to want us to think that, or they wouldn’t keep insisting that they are not healers. For whatever reason, when lamas are in the conventional world, (even though they are enlightened beings), they still appear to need conventional things, such as medical treatment. Perhaps the reason for this is so that people won’t come to them for the express purpose of having all of their medical ailments healed.
Sickness is basically purification of negative karma, (among ordinary people), so lamas understand that a lot of people actually need to be sick as a way to purify karma that would otherwise lead many to the lower realms. If one subscribes to this belief, it would actually be counter-productive (in the long run) for lamas to heal people who actually need an illness in order to purify their negative karma. So if lamas healed themselves all the time, people would see them as healers and converge on them for healing and you would see a long line that would stretch around the world, lol. So it would seem that even if lamas have the ability to heal themselves, they cannot outwardly display these abilities because they know where it would lead. They would have no time for Dharma teachings, which is the ultimate healer, because through Dharma teachings, one purifies the karma that leads to illnesses in the first place. So of course lamas want to focus on teaching people, not healing people of their physical ailments.
It seems that most lamas (regardless of who they are) are playing the game of needing to be healed, for whatever reason, in order to benefit others – or perhaps it is not a game. Maybe even enlightened beings have limits (in the conventional world) and perhaps even they cannot heal themselves the way people expect them to. Perhaps in these so-called degenerate times, even lamas are more limited in their abilities, even if they are enlightened. But in any case, Khadro-la is a healer and she is able to heal the sick, (when it is appropriate karmically to do so), so Lama Zopa is living proof that her healing actually does work. As long as it works, why do people have a problem with it? Does it matter what method they use, as long as he is healed?
diamond223
August 26, 2012
Thanks so much for the above informative articles. What I learn from the above is that….is better no to criticize on anything which you are not sure above it!
For an example…Khadro-la, She is an emanation of Tara and Vajrayogini, who is an enlightened Buddha….and NOT ONLY a female oracle of Goddess Tenma.
It’s true that Lama Zopa Rinpoche students has broken samaya with Him….but for Rinpoche to accept Khadro-la’s healing, which means Rinpoche knows who is She (Khadro-la)? Lama Zopa Rinpoche is a highly attained Lama….do not put Him down please….
Meliana
August 28, 2012
I am happy to hear Lama Zopa is better now. I pray his life is long so he can continue to heal others minds. But why Lama Zopa have to be heal by dakini? Is Dakini enlightened being? Or unenlightened being? How come Lama Zopa cannot help himself, if he can help other people? Or how come his students cannot ask Dharma protector like Dorje Shugden or Panden Llamo to heal him? Why they ask Dakini? Isn’t it danger to ask not enlightened being to heal your lama?
just a simple dharma practitioner
August 28, 2012
diamond223, I am not sure if you are saying I am putting Lama Zopa down or whether you are saying NKT is putting Lama Zopa down. Just for the record, I am not putting Lama Zopa down at all. I am saying that lamas in general seem to at least be playing the role of needing to be healed, so what difference does it make how it’s done? He’s better, so isn’t that good?
I would be very curious to know what is going to happen when NKT’s main
teacher gets sick, or at least when he manifests getting sick. If he calls on DS to heal him and nothing appears to happen, what then? Will people lose their faith? So, if he dies anyway, how will you explain that? Just wondering. It’s just something to think about and I’m not putting anybody down (not even NKT which I am not a part of). I am just commenting and asking some sincere questions because I am really curious to hear what the answer might be.
just a simple dharma practitioner
August 28, 2012
Just a follow up…
I am not saying NKT was putting Lama Zopa down either, just so you have that straight. I just feel that I can only speak for myself when I say that I wasn’t putting anybody down.
just a simple dharma practitioner
August 28, 2012
Meliana, Didn’t you read any of the above? Yes, the dakini IS an enlightened being. Why the heck do people think she isn’t? Also, I am rethinking what I myself and other people said about the goddess not being an enlightened being. I am not so sure that she wasn’t enlightened, since she was Milarepa’s consort, so she must have known a thing or two. The consort of Milarepa couldn’t possibly be a slouch in the spiritual realm, lol. (Khadro-la is the reincarnation/emanation of Milarepa’s consort.) Anyone qualified enough to do tantra with Milarepa has got to be a somewhat realized being, right?
gln
August 31, 2012
Only Buddha can recognize another Buddha. Period. So, to say somebody is a Buddha is at least can cause a problem in the future. Because we never know who is around.
As for Lama Zopa, he can be seen as a Buddha by his students, but that does not mean I must accept their view. Same goes to Khadro-la, if she is Vajrayogini or Tara in worldly form– we do not know.
But what we know is that Lama Zopa went against his own Guru Lama Yeshe by supporting the ban of Dorjeshugden. This is not an action of bodhisattva let alone action of a simple beginning buddhist. It is serious… HHDL also broke his own lama’s samaya. so, very hard for me to think of him as a bodhisattva or just even a monk…
gln
August 31, 2012
only because some students of lama zopa thinks of him to be bodhisattva does not make him bodhisattva. so, he could be just an ordinary person who broke his samaya to his lama and it is possible that the karma of breaking samaya is falling on him…
just a simple dharma practitioner
September 1, 2012
gln,
Well then, if *only* buddhas are allowed to recognize other buddhas, then who gets to determine whether DS is a buddha or not? I mean it works both ways, doesn’t it? Also, how does one know that HHDL’s guru and Lama Zopa’s guru (Lama Yeshe) didn’t come to them in their dreams and give them permission to give up DS practice? You’re assuming HHDL and Lama Zopa broke their samyaya, but maybe they communicated with their teachers in ways you weren’t able to see. Teachers often stay in touch with their students after death – on a spiritual level, so how do you know what private instructions were imparted to HHDL and Lama Zopa from their gurus?
Also, it’s not just MY unenlightened opinion that Khadro-la is an enlightened being. But if my teachers think so, I trust their judgement on the matter. After seeing her for myself (in person) I have to say that it felt amazing to be in her presence. She gives off that subtle “perfume” that enlightened beings have, which is hard to put into words. Of course, every one is free to believe that someone is or isn’t enlightened, so we can certainly agree on that. I’m with you there.
andrew hibberd
November 24, 2013
how fortunate was i to see Lhadro with the venerable Jampa Wangdu
how fortuanate was everyone else not even knowing shea was here
ha ha wake up get alife .
andrew hibberd
November 24, 2013
if i was so fortunate to see the panchen lama face to face i would recognise him like it was tomorrow
Jikme drakpa
December 5, 2013
If khandro la has really healed Lama Zopa, then there is nothing wrong it it. It is virtuous act that we should rejoice. But the question how can we proof that khandro has healed lama zopa. Lama zopa has been admitted hospital and is under the care of competent doctors, he has been also engaging in many meditations and ritual. How can we exclude these factors and then attribute only to Khandrola? Once there was very sick Tibetan girl , and the night Previous Zong Rinpoche did ritual, the next morning she was cured. In this case I can almost say for sure that it was Zong Rinpoche that healed the girl.
kelly wenham
February 13, 2015
OM TARE TUTTARE TURE SOHA . SIMPLY MAY ALL BEINGS HAVE HAPPINESS AND THE CAUSE OF HAPPINESS ,rEJOICE WE HAVE THE DHARMA AND LET GO OF JUDGEMENT.
Thaimonk
October 25, 2018
Too bad this had to happen- Lama Osel disrobed, never finished his studies, achieved nothing much in his secular life, just running around with his girlfriend and clubbing in Ibizia, Spain. His previous life accomplished so much with the help of his determination, hard work and Dorje Shugden. Lama Yeshe credited much of his success to the help he was bestowed by Dorje Shugden. By FPMT abanding Dorje Shugden, they broke their samaya with their lineage gurus such as Trijang Rinpoche and Zong Rinpoche from whom they received the Dorje Shugden sogtae commitment practice. Also it was with Lama Yeshe’s permission they received sogtae from these great masters. By abandoning the practice, they broke their spiritual bond (samaya) which is sacred in tantra with Lama Yeshe and lineage lamas. So it is no surprise Lama Yeshe came back in this incarnation unable to manifest being a great dharma teacher like his previous life. It is a shame and embarrassment to FPMT that Lama Osel ended up not doing much. It is a testimony to their failure in keeping their samaya to their guru and lineage lamas. FPMT wanted fame and rub shoulders with the famous and in return, they lost Lama Yeshe. After Lama Zopa passes away, FPMT will just go down for sure. No one can take over. Breaking their samaya was the wrong thing to do. 💔 I use to respect FPMT very much but not now. Not a good example in my eyes. Many senior FPMT people left because of this. 💔
So many more pictures and information to read here: http://www.dorjeshugden.com/forum/index.php?topic=6197.0
Tenzin Paljor
October 25, 2018
⌛️🕯🕯🕯
Lama Zopa, who has received sogtae (initiation of Dorje Shugden) from His Holiness Kyabje Trijang Rinpoche, had said that:
“Lama (Yeshe) and I practiced Shugden for many years. That was always the main thing that Lama did whenever there were problems to overcome. At the beginning of every Kopan course, Lama always did Shugden puja to eliminate hindrances.”
“My root guru, His Holiness Trijang Rinpoche; Pabongka Dechen Nyingpo, His Holiness the Dalai Lama’s guru’s root guru; His Holiness Zong Rinpoche, from whom many of the older students received the initiation of Shugden; and the previous incarnation of Gomo Rinpoche, who has a strong connection with Istituto Lama Tsongkhapa, here in Italy, all promoted the practice of Shugden.”
Photos: 1) Teachings by H.H. Kyabje Zong Rinpoche to FPMT students. 2) As Lama Yeshe reached the end of his life, Kyabje Zong Rinpoche came to the hospital to do prayers for Lama Yeshe. Lama Yeshe was very devoted to Kyabje Zong Rinpoche and Dorje Shugden till the end.
🕯
Toby
October 25, 2018
In FPMT’s centre called Tushita in Dharamsala, North India, they have a statue of Lama Yeshe in the form of Vajrasattva with consort. Now the question is simple: If Lama Yeshe practised Dorje Shugden, then he is a bad lama, so why doesn’t FPMT stop the homage/respect to their founding father Lama Yeshe? If they trust him, they will go to three lower realms for worshipping Lama Yeshe who worshipped Dorje Shugden. And all statues of Lama Yeshe should be discarded from all their centres right? In fact, in nearby Gaden Choling Nunnery in Dharamsala, the nun’s took their Dorje Shugden statue out of their main prayer hall where it was worshipped for decades and destroyed the statue in the garbage dump and jumped up and down on it to further desecrate it.
Furthermore they make a Dorje Shugden worshipping Lama Yeshe in the form of divinity as Buddha Vajrasattva. That is a double-whammy no right? Why is FPMT so contradictory? Why are they blind to this double standard?
If they wish to disassociate from Dorje Shugden lamas, they have to disassociate from their own centre-founding Lama who is Lama Yeshe. They must set the example right. Everyone knows Lama Yeshe worshipped, trusted and believed in Dorje Shugden till the end of his life. Lama Yeshe is the one that founded FPMT, so they have to be clean across the board and be honest right? If disassociate, then do it all the way. They should have no pictures, statues and images of Lama Yeshe at all. They should not be making images of him as a deity (Vajrasattva) as that is even more wrong according to their stance against Shugden and Shugden Lamas.
Why encourage their members to worship a Dorje Shugden loving Lama like Lama Yeshe? That is what they are doing when they keep all his images in their centres around the world. They are sending the wrong message out. Lama Yeshe was wrong in their view to practice Dorje Shugden. Lama Yeshe broke his refuge vows by practicing Dorje Shugden. Lama Yeshe’s lineage, teachings, initiations and commentaries are all corrupted because he worshipped Dorje Shugden. So they should ritually expel his images from their centres with immediate effect to be in the clean arena.
The Dalai Lama said if you worship Dorje Shugden, no one should associate with you and you will go to hell. So how come FPMT still keeps a statue of Lama Yeshe in many of their centres? Is that not hypocrisy?
Pics attached: Lama Yeshe as Vajrasattva with Consort housed in Tushita Centre-Dharamsala AND Lama Zopa prostrating to a statue of Lama Yeshe
Lophun
October 25, 2018
I do not understand how a Lama like Lama Rinpoche can write things like this, when it is well-known that he himself gave Dorje Shugden initiations and told the initiates that they were incurring a lifelong obligation to continue the practice, and that breaking such an obligation would incur grave negative karma. It is very confusing and frankly, depressing.
Lama Zopa has written some excellent books, such as his work on the Medicine Buddha. However, his logic in this foreword is gravely flawed and perhaps even essentially anti-Buddhist. For instance, he says, “If the Precious Victorious One, His Holiness the Dalai Lama, is not the actual Buddha and Arya Avalokiteshvara, then you can say that in this world there is no emanation of Buddha benefiting sentient beings. In this way bodhicitta and the entire teachings of the Buddha become false.”
Say what??? I do not know whether the Dalai Lama is or is not an emanation of Avalokiteshvara, though, based on his words and actions, I sincerely doubt it. (I mean, the man has repeatedly stated in countless interviews that he is not enlightened, and seems to relish scoffing at the notion that he might be). Regardless, the fact that the Dalai Lama is or is not such an emanation has nothing whatsoever to do with whether there are other emanations of Buddha currently on earth benefitting sentient beings.
Logically, one does not rule out the possibility that other living Buddhas exist today, or other emanations of Avalokiteshvara, simply by denying that the Dalai Lama is such a one. If I deny that my wife is a panda bear, I am not denying that pandas exist. Indeed, to make a claim of exclusivity on the Dalai Lama’s behalf, as Lama Zopa has done, is really anti-Mahayanan in spirit, for it belittles and denigrates the efficacy of all other Buddhist schools and traditions. Someone seems to have imported the Roman Catholic doctrine of papal infallibility into Dharamsala, and now they are beginning to round up the infidels and burn them at the stake.
It is the height of irony that Lama Zopa urges practitioners to examine their beliefs openly and honestly, and then states as a matter of fact that the Dalai Lama is omniscient and one must adhere to what the ‘omniscient one’ says. Am I not permitted to question whether the Dalai Lama is truly omniscient, and to judge this claim by the evidence of the man’s words and actions? Am I not allowed to take him at his word when he says he is NOT omniscient? Am I not allowed to question his lack of success in defending the cause of Tibet, or his lack of compassion in his treatment of Shugden practitioners, or his bumbling manner in any number of interviews, or his willingness to be used as a CIA puppet or guest editor of a highly immoral fashion magazine?
Sadly, the recent actions of Lama Zopa and the Dalai Lama have completely soured me on Tibetan Buddhism. I have been forced to turn back to the Theravadan and Chinese teachings, because I will never again turn my will and intellect over to a guru who demands total obedience, even when he teaches one thing today and a completely different thing tomorrow. With this version of Buddhism, it’s a heads-you-win, tails-I-lose situation for the sincere follower … any faults of the guru are really the fault of the practitioner, whose bad karma has caused those faults to manifest. And even when the guru manifests obvious error, he still is not to be questioned because the error again is in the eye of the practitioner and only through blind loyalty can he cleanse his karma to the point where sincere questioning is of any value. If this is the case, then there is no point in advising practitioners to question and judge the teachings, because their bad karma will not allow them to make reasonable judgments. Reason itself is banished; it has become soiled and fallen and no longer can be trusted. Blind obedience becomes the only permitted path … you must believe in the Dalai Lama because he is a priori infallible and any evidence to the contrary is not credible, because ONLY the Dalai Lama represents Buddha in today’s world and EVERYONE ELSE is deluded.
And so the question arises: if I am required to have blind faith in the Dalai Lama in order to be “saved”, what separates this form of Buddhism from any other exclusivist, country-club members only, religion? What separates Buddhism from the monotheistic religions once reason has been outlawed? You can use the same “your bad karma prevents you from seeing things as they are” argument to justify any religion, any cult, any superstition, any belief whatsoever. It might take a slightly different form — “your ways are not God’s ways,” or “your reason was broken in the original fall from grace of sinful man,” but the essence is the same: don’t trust yourself, look to others, particularly those who are held up as masters, for the truth. In this way, Lama Zopa’s attempt to defend the Dalai Lama becomes an atomic weapon capable of destroying any and all religious belief, or empowering any and all zealots of every stripe.
I find all of this unworthy of the spirit of inquiry I believe Buddha Shakyamuni promoted, and the spirit of compassion that Avalokiteshvara represents. I hope that one day all the confusion that these modern-day avatars have sowed will be cleared up and those of us who relied upon them as examples and guides on the spiritual path will have our disappointments honestly and frankly acknowledged and rectified.
Comment left by a Howard from http://www.dorjeshugden.com/all-articles/the-controversy/recognized-by-dorje-shugden-but-speaks-against-dorje-shugden/comment-page-1/#comment-911810
Picture attached: HH Kyabje Zong Rinpoche performs last rites for Venerable Lama Yeshe. Both these lamas were totally devoted to Dorje Shugden until the end of their lives. Decades later, Lama Zopa who has abandoned his guru Lama Yeshe’s practice of Dorje Shugden, to befriend the Dalai Lama.